"Xero vs MYOB vs QuickBooks: Which Accounting Software Suits a Small Business in Australia?"

Xero, MYOB and QuickBooks Online can all handle the basics an Australian small business needs — invoicing, bank feeds, GST and BAS, and payroll with Single Touch Payroll. None is "the best" for everyone. The right choice depends on your industry, whether you have staff, which apps you need to connect, and who will keep the books. Good setup matters more than which brand you pick.
"Which accounting software should I use?" is one of the first questions new business owners ask — and the honest answer is that Xero, MYOB and QuickBooks are all solid choices in Australia. What causes problems is usually not the software. It's how it was set up and how it's kept up to date.
What all three do
Xero, MYOB and QuickBooks Online are all cloud accounting programs. On their standard plans, each can generally:
- Send invoices and quotes, and track who owes you money
- Pull in transactions automatically from your business bank account (bank feeds)
- Track GST and prepare the figures for your BAS
- Run payroll and report to the ATO through Single Touch Payroll (STP) — on plans or add-ons that include payroll
- Capture receipts from your phone
- Give your accountant or bookkeeper access to the same file
So for most small businesses, the choice is less "which one can do it" and more "which one fits the way you work".
Where they differ
Xero — very popular with small businesses and accountants in Australia. It has a large marketplace of connected apps (point-of-sale, booking systems, inventory, receipt apps), which suits businesses that already use other software.
MYOB — an Australian company that has been around for decades. Many established businesses and bookkeepers have used it for years, and it has strong Australian payroll features.
QuickBooks Online — used worldwide and known for being simple to start with. It's a common choice for sole traders and small service businesses that mainly need invoicing and expense tracking.
You may also hear of Reckon, another Australian option that some small businesses and bookkeepers still use.
Plans and prices change often, and features differ between plans. Before you sign up, check the current plan on each provider's website, especially if you need payroll, multiple currencies or inventory.
Popular apps that connect to your accounting software
Much of the real time-saving comes from the apps around your accounting software. Common ones in Australian small businesses include:
- Point of sale and payments: Square, Lightspeed, Shopify, Stripe, PayPal
- Rostering and payroll: Deputy, Employment Hero
- Receipts and bills: Dext, Hubdoc (from Xero)
- Booking systems for salons, massage and service businesses
Before you choose, check which of your apps connect directly and how the data comes across. A POS that sends daily sales, card fees and payouts in a clean summary makes the books much easier than one that sends every single transaction.
How to choose
Ask yourself:
- Do you have employees? If yes, make sure the plan includes payroll and STP, and that it can handle super being paid every payday under Payday Super (from 1 July 2026).
- What do you already use? If your POS, booking or e-commerce system connects well with one program, that's a strong reason to pick it.
- Who will do the books? If you have a bookkeeper or accountant, use the software they work with every day — it saves time and fees.
- How many transactions do you have? A sole trader with a handful of invoices a month needs far less than a restaurant with daily card takings and staff.
- Do you need inventory or job costing? Check that the plan you're looking at actually includes it.
The twist: the software doesn't do your bookkeeping
Bank feeds bring transactions in, but someone still has to code them correctly. The most common problems we see:
- Wrong GST codes — for example bank fees or wages coded as if they include GST, which makes the BAS wrong
- Personal and business spending mixed together in one account
- Auto-rules set up once and never checked, quietly coding hundreds of transactions to the wrong account
- Switching software mid-year without a clean cut-off, so opening balances don't match
A well-set-up file in any of the three is far better than a messy file in the "best" one.
Do you even need software yet?
If you're a new sole trader with low income and few expenses, a separate business bank account and a simple record of income and receipts may be enough at first. Once you register for GST, take on staff or your volume grows, accounting software usually pays for itself in time saved.
How Bevton & Co can help
We work with Xero, MYOB and QuickBooks Online. If you already use one, we work in your file — bookkeeping, bank reconciliations, BAS and payroll. If you're starting out, we'll help you choose the one that fits your business and set it up properly from day one.
FAQ
Which is better for a sole trader: Xero, MYOB or QuickBooks?
All three work for sole traders. If you mostly send invoices and track expenses, choose the one you find easiest to use, or the one your accountant already works with. If you plan to register for GST or hire staff later, check that the plan can grow with you.
Can these programs lodge my BAS?
They prepare the GST and PAYG figures for your BAS, and some plans can lodge it with the ATO. The figures are only as accurate as the bookkeeping behind them, so it's worth having them reviewed before lodging.
Do all three support Single Touch Payroll?
Yes, all three offer STP-enabled payroll for Australian businesses, but payroll may only be included on certain plans or as an add-on. Check the current plan details before you sign up.
Can I switch from one program to another?
Yes. It's easiest to switch at the start of a financial year or a BAS quarter, with clean opening balances. Moving mid-period without a proper cut-off is a common cause of mismatched figures.
Want this done properly for your situation?
Email us a few details and we'll tell you what you need and what it costs — before any work starts.
General information only — not personal tax advice. Tax rules and rates change; figures are for the year stated.


